Where can I buy New York style cookies?

Short answer: in the Netherlands, the easiest way to get real New York style cookies is to order them online. At Crookie Club we bake them fresh in Lelystad and ship them across the country with PostNL, so they land on your doorstep wherever you live.

Option 1: order online (easiest)

Here's how ordering from Crookie Club works:

1. Pick your cookies. Single cookies are €3.50. Boxes save you money: 3 for €9.50, 6 for €17, or 12 for €34 with a 13th cookie free.
2. Pick your date. We bake to order, so choose a date at least 48 hours ahead.
3. Pay with iDEAL, card, Apple Pay or Google Pay.
4. Get your cookies. We deliver ourselves in Lelystad and ship with PostNL everywhere else.

👉 Build your box

Option 2: local delivery in Lelystad

Live in Lelystad (postcode 8200–8245)? We bring your cookies ourselves, Tuesday to Saturday. Delivery is free from €34. See New York cookies in Lelystad.

New York cookies in your city

We ship to every city in the Netherlands. Here are a few of the places we send cookies to most:

• New York cookies in Amsterdam
• New York cookies in Rotterdam
• New York cookies in Utrecht
• New York cookies in The Hague
• New York cookies in Almere
• New York cookies in Groningen
• New York cookies in Eindhoven

Or see all cities.

What to look for in a New York style cookie

Not every big cookie is a New York cookie. A real one is:

• thick and heavy, not flat,
• golden and crisp at the edges,
• soft and gooey in the middle,
• baked fresh, ideally to order.

New to the style? Read What is an NYC style cookie?

Which flavour should I buy first?

If you're not sure, start with our best sellers: Chocolate Chip, M&M's, Biscoff and Red Velvet. A box of 6 lets you try all four (and double up on your favourite).

Buying for an event or a team?

For 50 cookies or more we deliver within 7 days, with an invoice. Perfect for kick-offs, client gifts or a thank-you to the team. Request a quote.