Top 7
The best NYC cookies in Lelystad
Looking for the best NYC cookies in Lelystad? You're in the right place, because we bake them right around the corner. These are the flavours Lelystad orders most.
A birthday in Warande, drinks after a day at Batavia Stad or just a Friday night on the sofa. In Lelystad, we are never far away.
Our ranking
- 1Photo coming soon

1. Chocolate Chip Best seller
The benchmark for every NYC cookie. If the chocolate chip is right, the rest will be too. Ours is thick, golden at the edge and soft in the middle.
Best for: Purists and first-timers
€3.50 - 2

2. M&M's Best seller
The happiest cookie on the list. Crunchy M’s, white chocolate and sprinkles. Always the first to go at a party.
Best for: Kids’ parties and birthdays
€3.50 - 3Photo coming soon

3. Biscoff Best seller
Speculoos flavour with a gooey heart. For anyone who already melts for a Lotus biscuit with their coffee.
Best for: With coffee
€3.50 - 4

4. Red Velvet Best seller
Bright red, velvety soft and generous with white chocolate. The cookie that looks good in every photo.
Best for: Valentine’s, weddings and Instagram
€3.50 - 5Photo coming soon

5. Triple Chocolate
Three kinds of chocolate in a cocoa dough. Rich, deep and exactly what you want on a rainy day.
Best for: True chocoholics
€3.50 - 6Photo coming soon

6. Stroopwafel
New York meets the Netherlands. Caramel syrup and stroopwafel pieces in a thick cookie. Our pride and joy.
Best for: Visitors and Dutch gifts
€3.50 - 7

7. Marshmallow
Melted marshmallow with milk and white chocolate. That campfire feeling, without the campfire.
Best for: Cosy nights on the sofa
€3.50
Why these cookies?
A real NYC cookie is thick (often around 2 cm), much heavier than a regular cookie and golden on the outside while the middle stays soft and almost gooey. We bake them in small batches in Lelystad, and only after you order.
💡 Tip for Lelystad
Live in Lelystad (postcode 8200–8245)? Choose local delivery at checkout. Orders from €34 are delivered free.
Order them in Lelystad
